Writer E. Jean Carroll accused Donald Trump of sexually assaulting her inside a Manhattan department store in the mid-1990s. Trump denied the accusations and claimed he had never met Carroll, even though photos exist of the two at a social event in 1987. Carroll subsequently sued Trump for defamation, claiming his denials hurt her reputation.
Legal Proceedings and Verdicts
A federal jury in New York in May 2023 found Trump liable for sexually abusing and defaming Carroll. The jury later awarded her $5 million in damages. Trump appealed the verdict, but on Dec. 30, 2024, the Second U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the decision, brushing aside his claims of trial errors.
Additional Defamation and Damages
After the first verdict, Trump continued to issue public statements denying Carroll’s accusations. Carroll did and filed a second defamation suit in response. In January 2024, a jury ordered Trump to pay another $83.3 million in damages for those statements.
Trump’s Legal Strategies and Appeals
Trump’s legal team has vehemently denied Carroll’s allegations and has condemned the court’s decision. They have appealed numerous times, contesting both the verdicts and the damages awarded. However, the original decisions have mostly been upheld by the courts.
Implications for Trump’s Public Image
These legal battles have significantly impacted Trump’s public image, especially as he prepares to assume the presidency again. The upheld verdicts and substantial financial penalties underscore the serious nature of the allegations and the court’s stance on such matters.
Carroll’s Perspective and Legal Representation
E. Jean Carroll has said she felt relief and satisfaction at the court’s rulings. Carroll’s lawyer, Roberta Kaplan, played an important role in helping steer through a complex legal process to establish Carroll’s right to the judgment.
Broader Context of Sexual Assault Allegations
This case is part of a broader pattern of sexual assault allegations against Trump. Several women have made similar accusations, which Trump has repeatedly denied. Carroll’s legal fate could also shape how future allegations are received and dealt with.
